Best Ice Fishing Shelter 2020 – Reviews And Top Picks

New different models of the best ice fishing shelters have gone on sale lately. Prices on these absolutely necessary devices for winter fishing differ a lot, as their features are diverse. Last winter I was ill-informed and less experienced, so I wasted a considerable sum on a useless stuff. Do not repeat my mistakes and read this article, where I compared the most popular tents on the market, their features, pros and cons.

  • Elkton Outdoors Fishing Tent
  • Rating:
  • Size: 137.5 x 68.5 x 81
  • Insulated: Yes(Three Layers Of Quilted PVC,Nylon & Tarpaulin For Extra Protection)
  • Weight: 35 LBS
  • Carrying Bag: with Easy Load Top & Adjustable Backpack Straps
  • Users: 6-8
Name
Size:
Insulated:
Weight:
Carrying Bag:
Users:
Price
Name
Size:
Insulated:
Weight:
Carrying Bag:
Users:
Price
№1
65 x 8.2 x 8.2
Yes
34 LBS
no info
3-4
№2
137.5 x 68.5 x 81
Yes(Three Layers Of Quilted PVC,Nylon & Tarpaulin For Extra Protection)Show More
35 LBS
with Easy Load Top & Adjustable Backpack StrapsShow More
6-8
№3
140″ x 70″ x 80″
No
40 LBS
Yes
6
№6
50 x 32 x 10
IceTight
52 LBS
no info
1
№7
170 x 145 x 145
No
22 LBS
Yes
2-3

A bit heavy and awkward to carry; this perfectly constructed shelter is especially good for dry weather. It warms up quickly and has a lot of space. There are eight big windows that provide a lot of light and the ability to monitor the situation outside.

Size:
65 x 8.2 x 8.2
Insulated:
Yes
Weight:
34 LBS
Carrying Bag:
no info
Users:
3-4
PROS
  • windproof
  • storage pockets
  • easy to assemble and install
  • stability
  • great for dry, predictable weather
  • roomy
Cons
  • thin material
  • easy to tear
  • non-waterproof
  • heavy
  • non-insulated
  • poor zippers
  • a rather small bag.

This waterproof and warm tent comes with a useful carry bag with extra straps. Moreover, it has six special gaps for ventilation, allowing you to control the airflow and pockets for strafing different items. Pockets provide easy access to your things, and it does not take up a lot of space.

Size:
137.5 x 68.5 x 81
Insulated:
Yes(Three Layers Of Quilted PVC,Nylon & Tarpaulin For Extra Protection)
Weight:
35 LBS
Carrying Bag:
with Easy Load Top & Adjustable Backpack Straps
Users:
6-8
PROS
  • useful window
  • carrying bag with backpack straps 
  • ice anchors
  • tie-down ropes
  • waterproof
  • windproof
  • storage pockets
  • storage hammock
  • easy to assemble and install
  • stability
  • insulated
  • durable zippers
Cons
  • poor grommets
  • poor straps

This price-effective tent is good for two people. However, it is applicable only for dry or snowy weather, as it is not waterproof. There are some drawbacks, but all of them are justified by the reasonable price. It is very easy to assemble it alone.

Size:
140″ x 70″ x 80″
Insulated:
No
Weight:
40 LBS
Carrying Bag:
Yes
Users:
6
PROS
  • very light and easy to carry
  • windproof
  • roomy
  • easy to assemble and install
  • durable
  • holds heat well
Cons
  • small door
  • non-waterproof
  • not very tall
  • small storage bag

This portable fish house is roomy and lightweight. A good option for a group of two to three people. It comes with eight ice anchors in a set, which makes it more stable. The tent is very durable due to the 300 denier fabric.

Size:
90 x 90 x 80
Insulated:
Yes
Weight:
20.5 LBS
Carrying Bag:
Yes
Users:
3
PROS
  • roomy
  • durable
  • windproof
  • 8 ice anchors
  • easy to assemble and install
Cons
  • one door
  • heavy
  • non-insulated
  • poor zippers
  • a rather small bag
Elkton Outdoors Portable 3-8 Person Ice Fishing Tent

This portable fish house is one of the most stable options on the market due to its form. It’s quite spacious inside, and it preserves heat for a long time. A convenient bag makes it the perfect option for long walks. However, it is absolutely non-waterproof, and that narrows its instances of use.

Size:
70 x 70 x 80
Insulated:
No
Weight:
24.4 LBS
Carrying Bag:
no info
Users:
3-4
PROS
  • useful window
  • carrying bag with backpack straps
  • windproof
  • storage pockets
  • storage hammock
  • easy to assemble and install
  • stability
Cons
  • thin material
  • single stitching
  • not waterproof
  • poor straps
  • not insulated

Very small and easy to carry, this shelter is perfect for solo fishing. It warms up quickly and saves the heat pretty well. There are two windows, which make it quite light.

Size:
50 x 32 x 10
Insulated:
IceTight
Weight:
52 LBS
Carrying Bag:
no info
Users:
1
PROS
  • very easy to carry
  • windproof
  • storage pockets
  • easy to assemble and install
  • durable
  • cheap
Cons

small and cramped

AYNEFY Winter Fishing Tent comes with multifunctional windows, which can be easily opened. There is an extra ultraviolet-resistant layer on the tissue. It weighs only eight kilograms, and that is comparatively lightweight, which makes it perfect for carrying. It is made of durable quality 300D oxford cloth.

Size:
170 x 145 x 145
Insulated:
No
Weight:
22 LBS
Carrying Bag:
Yes
Users:
2-3
PROS
  • useful window
  • extra UV-resistant treatment
  • waterproof
  • windproof
  • easy assembly and installation
Cons

not stable

How to Choose Ice Fishing Shelter – Buyer’s Guide

Before you buy a tent for ice fishing, you should understand some nuances. In the market of fishing goods tents are represented by a large number of models, and the spread of prices for them may confuse even an experienced fisherman. Therefore, we have made a guide that will help to deal with these issues.

Types of Ice Fishing Shelters

Each type of winter tent has its own pros and cons, so it is very difficult to choose the best one. It all depends on what conditions you have chosen to fish in during the winter. We will consider each type separately.

Windbreakers

A light and easy to carry a shelter, that perfectly protects you from the wind.

Pros:

  • Weight. Light and comfortable tent for a quick change of location.
  • Installation. It can be installed in minutes.
  • Stability. Thanks to the shape with evenly inclined walls, a gust of wind will not blow the tent off the ice but press it down.

Cons:

  • Less insulated

Cabin

Two-angle ice fishing tent that is easy to install and has insulation.

Pros:

  • Price. Usually not very expensive
  • Fast installation

Cons:

  • Rather heavy

Flip-Over

A light and small shelter for one person.

Pros:

  • Quick installation.
  • Weight. Due to the lack of a rigid frame, it weighs very little.
  • Transportation. Lightweight ensures easy transportation.

Cons:

  • Locks. Some fishermen complain about the quality of the locks installed.
  • Wind resistance of the frame. Due to the fact that the frame does not have stiffeners, the entire structure can break down in windy weather.
  • Only for one person.

Hub style shelters

One of the most popular types of automatic shantys in the fishing market. A tent in the form of a cube with convex walls.

Pros:

  • Expanse. A fisherman can easily stand up to his full height and stretch his stiff, sore legs.
  • Rigid frame made of fiberglass.

Cons:

  • Stability. Because of their size and shape, these tents are not stable.
  • Price. One of the most expensive types of tents.
  • Mobility. Because of weight, these tents are more suitable for fishing in one place.

Material Used in The Production and Their Temperature Features

The best and most expensive option is to choose a polyester fabric. Nylon fabrics are cheaper, but inferior in their characteristics: water resistance, strength, and durability. Tarpaulin fabrics in comparison with the named above-are heavy, especially after getting wet. However, tarpaulin is warmer.

The Importance of Wind-Resistance, Insulation, and Ventilation

If you are planning to use gas burners or lamps for heating, then choose a tent with ventilation. In tents with stove heating, special attention should be paid to the places of their installation. Winter tents have special “skirts” that secure them from wind and snow. Ice fishing shanties are insulated with additional awnings.

Ventilation. When spending the night during winter months, it is always necessary to provide ventilation — otherwise, condensation forms on the walls, which reduces the thermal insulation properties.

In addition, heating without ventilation threatens the formation of high concentrations of carbon monoxide and poisoning. You can create an additional, second, or third layer on top of the tent from covering materials – for example, polyethylene. This is a good option for additional insulation.

Weight of the Shelter and Its Portability

The best ice fishing shelter should be as light as possible, as well as mobile and compact. A distinctive feature of the winter tent is quick installation. In cold conditions, the installation should not take a lot of time.

Preparation Before the Trip

After buying a winter tent, install it before traveling. It is necessary to make sure that the tent is not skewed, stretched evenly, and symmetrically. Also, pre-installation and inspection of the tent will allow you to quickly and easily install it in the field. Ideally, the time for assembling and disassembling should not exceed 10-15 seconds, so it is better to pay attention to the tents with an automatic installation mechanism.

Seating Area

The seating area is a very important issue. It must be roomy and comfortable, as you may spend a lot of time waiting for a fish. Nowadays, some of the models are provided with fitted chairs.

Size and Capacity of Your Tent

Decide how big of a tent you need – single, double, or triple. If your tent for winter fishing is less two meters in diameter – then it is considered single, and if more a double.

In cases where you need a winter tent for three or four men – look for a tent that is more than three meters in diameter. The diameter is the distance between the opposite corners of the tent. The number of users is usually written on the package.

How Much Does Ice Fishing Shelter Cost

Important parameters when choosing an ice fishing shanty are the quality of materials, reliability of the frame, and functional equipment of the tent. We do not advise you to buy a cheap model.

However, try not to overpay for a winter tent because the market is represented by hundreds of manufacturers, which, in turn, produces various models for different purposes. From ultralight tents for expeditions, which are very expensive, to tents designed for temperatures from +5 to 0 without the possibility of long-term usage.

FAQ

We have prepared a section to answer the most common questions about the best ice fishing shelters.

Is There Any Difference Between Ordinary and Insulated Tents?

Tents are produced with a single-layer fabric, and with different options of insulation. Insulated tents weigh much more and are more expensive, and their usage is advisable if the temperature outside the window steadily falls below -20°C. In other cases, the use of a single-layer tent, together with heating sources, is justified.

Is It Possible to Spend the Night In a Tent?

Tents for fishermen come in two options. The first type is prefabricated (automatically laid out and assembled). Such designs command little space, are easy and useful for fishing with frequent changes of location, but are not suitable for overnight or long stays. The main function of these types of tents is to protect you from wind and snow. These devices are usually designed for one person.

The second type is a frame tent. They have a stronger base, a frame of folding arches, or racks. This type is heavier but more comfortable. It can perform not only the function of protection from the wind but is suitable for the organization of overnight stays and installation of furnace equipment.

What is The Best Bent Style?

This issue is rather disputable. Of course, every fisherman finds the most applicable model for himself. Each style has its pros and cons, so you have to find the most suitable option for you.

What Tent Accessories Do I Need to Purchase?

We have prepared a list of accessories that may be useful for ice fishing.

Fishing bait bucket

The use of a special bucket reduces preparation time for fishing and allows you to concentrate on fishing. Such buckets are suitable for mixing and moistening the bait, as well as for carrying fish.

Find out the best bait bucket.

Fishing chair

The chair for fishing greatly increases the comfort of fishing, makes it possible to minimize physical costs, and to some extent, optimizes the fishing process.

Find out the best fishing chair.

Fishing led light

Lanterns are an indispensable item when fishing. Conventional devices are inconvenient to use, as they significantly limit the capabilities of a person. Therefore, it is worth buying a convenient headlamp, the bright beam of which will always be directed to the desired point. The most popular models are rechargeable led models.

Find out the best fishing led light.

Fishing rod holder

A holder for fishing rods is necessary for anyone who goes on a winter fishing trip because it is convenient, leaves your hands free, and you can do other things. Also, when fishing during the winter, your hands freeze less if they do not have to hold the rod all the time.

Find out the best fishing rod holder.

Tackle box

The Tackle Box system is a complete tackle storage system designed to ensure that you have the maximum possible number of sets with the minimum volume of the box.

Find out the best tackle boxes.

Sleds

A sled is a truly indispensable tool for ice fishing, especially when you need to walk a few kilometers on a slippery or snow-covered surface of the pond. But in the case of stationary fishing, when the place of fishing is not very far from the parking lot, fishing sleds are also useful.

Find out the best ice fishing sleds.

Heater

The heating of a tent in winter is necessary, not only to ensure a comfortable temperature inside the tent. One of the main tasks of heating is to prevent freezing of the hole, which at sub-zero air temperature is covered with an ice crust in a few minutes.

Find out the best tent heaters.

Conclusion

Taking into account all our tips, you will be able to choose a best ice fishing shelter that is suitable for you and perfectly fits the conditions of your hunt. We wish you a successful catch and hope your tent will be warm and cozy.

Users Rating:
5 / 5.0
2 User Voted
Add Your Rating:
Comments (4)
By:
OnlyCheese

Can a portable fish house be used in warm weather? If yes, which one?

    By:
    Chris Hayes
    To:
    OnlyCheese

    Sure, only make sure the weather is dry or if the tent is waterproof. The frame tents can even be used like standard outdoor tents.

By:
Bohemian Rhapsody 01

Is the Eskimo Fatfish Pop-up Ice Fishing Shanty water-resistant?

    By:
    Chris Hayes
    To:
    Bohemian Rhapsody 01

    Unfortunately, no. It is wind-resistant, but it won’t protect you from wet snow or rain.

Leave a reply
* Your email address will not be published.
Editors Choice:
img
Eskimo FatFish Pop-up Portable Ice Shelter